[Math] Magnitude of a Vector in Spherical Coordinates with No Radial Component

physicsspherical coordinatesvectors

Logically, it seems like the magnitude of a vector in spherical coordinates should just be the radial component, but if the vector has a radial component of zero, does that make the magnitude zero?

It seems like this shouldn't be the case, since in physics, we sometimes can have, say, a velocity vector with no radial component. We usually say speed is the magnitude of velocity, but in cases like this, the speed does not seem to be zero. So what is it?

Best Answer

The magnitude of a vector whose spherical coordinate "radial" component is zero is... zero.

Consider the path (in $(r, \theta, \phi)$) coordinates $$ u(t)= (2t, 0, 0). $$

At $t = 0$, this passes through the origin.

Its derivative (in spherical polar coordinates again) is $$ u'(t) = (2, 0, 0) $$ At $t = 0$, this derivative is, in spherical coordinates, $(2, 0, 0)$, which is not zero, which reflects the fact that $u$ is a path that travels along a diameter of a sphere at constant speed, so its speed, at any moment, should indeed be nonzero.