[Math] Is it legal to put $\tan$ on both sides of the equation

calculustrigonometry

I have this equation and I need to find $x$ variable:

$$1+\frac{\pi}{4}-x=\arctan x$$

can I put $\tan$ on RHS and LHS in order to find $x$:

$$\tan( 1+\frac{\pi}{4}-x)=\tan(\arctan x)$$

Secondly, after I have $x$ on RHS, how am I supposed to find $x$ if the LHS has now become a complicated expression?

Best Answer

It is certainly true that if $1+\dfrac\pi4-x=\arctan x$ then $\tan\left(1+\dfrac\pi4-x\right)=\tan(\arctan x).$

But it is not true that if $\tan\left(1+\dfrac\pi4-x\right)=\tan(\arctan x)$ then $1+\dfrac\pi4-x=\arctan x,$ since $\tan$ is not a one-to-one function.

In other words, some of the solutions of the latter equation are not solutions of the former, so you'll need to check for extraneous roots.

Related Question