[Math] free vector space of the product space

linear algebratensors

Suppose that $V_1, V_2$ are two real vector spaces. Consider the free vector space $\mathscr{F}(V_1 \times V_2)$ which consists of finite linear combinations of elements of $V_1 \times V_2$. How is it different from the product vector space $V_1 \times V_2$ itself?

I think they should be the same, but in Lee's Introduction to Smooth manifolds, he considers the free vector space instead of the vector space itself. Why?

enter image description here

Best Answer

These are very different. Are you aware of what the free vector space on a set $X$ is? It is a vector space $\mathscr F(X)$ with $X$ as a basis. In particular, if you choose to be $X$ to be equal to be a real vector space $V$, then $\mathscr F(V)$ is a real vector space which has $V$ as a basis. So if, for example, $V=\Bbb R$, then $V$ is a finite dimensional real vector space, but $\mathscr F(V)$ is a vector space with dimension of cardinality $\Bbb R$, and $\mathscr F(V)$ is indeed very different to $V$.

To say it in a different way, $\mathscr F(V)$ is all "formal combinations" of elements of $V$. The typical addition and scalar multiplation from $V$ doesn't apply here. So in particular, in $\mathscr F(V\times V')$, the elements $(v,0)+(0,v')$ and $(v,v')$ are different elements, even though they are the same as elements of $V\times V'$.

Related Question