[Math] Does a Person Need a Mathematics Degree in order to Publish in a Mathematics jounal

publishingsoft-question

I am a neophyte amateur mathematician. I have been reading a lot about journals and the topic of peer-review in mathematics journals. Does one have to have professional credentials or have a Doctorate in order to publish in peer-reviewed mathematics journals or just the desire to compently solve mathematical problems?

Best Answer

No, no sort of degree or specific credentials are required. It is far from unheard of that someone publishes one or more papers while still an undergraduate. There are even a few instances of important work being published by high school students.

If you are an uncredentialled mathematician you should take extra pains to make sure that your work passes superficial tests for looking serious and competent. Off the top of my head, this would include the following:

  1. Make sure that your grammar and spelling is virtually flawless (in particular, you have some spelling mistakes in your post, which is probably not such a big deal for this site, but would create a bad impression in a journal submission).

  2. Use some form of TeX to format your document. (This is freely available online and just takes a little practice to become reasonably proficient. Not to do so is a big warning sign of outsider status.)[1]

  3. Make sure that your work contains a bibliography which gives due acknowledgment to previous work in the field. Wherever possible, you should try to cite primary sources (i.e., journal papers) or standard texts, and you should try to avoid citing things like wikipedia and popular books.

[1] I am aware that there are a few leading mathematicians who do not use TeX. The geometer Cliff Taubes is a popular example. However, Professor Taubes began his mathematical career before TeX became widespread and, in any event, does not need any help in getting his work taken seriously. I am not saying that someone who does not follow the above precepts is not a serious mathematician, just that they look less like one at a first impression.

Related Question