[Math] Do convergence in distribution along with uniform integrability imply convergence in mean

convergence-divergencemeasure-theoryprobability theoryrandom variablesuniform-integrability

There are at least 2 places in Wikipedia saying that $X_n$ converges to $X$ in mean in and only if $X_n$ converges to $X$ in probability and $X_n$ is uniformly integrable. See the following link for example:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convergence_of_random_variables#Properties_4

However, I found a reference in Billingsley's book saying that we only need convergence in distribution along with uniform integrability to imply the convergence in mean. Is Wikipedia wrong, or am I missing something here?

Thanks.

Best Answer

I don't have Billingsley's book here, but I guess what he says is that uniform integrability and convergence in distribution imply convergence of the means (and not in mean), i.e. $E[X_n]$ converges to $E[X]$.

One simple (though not truely elementary) way to see it is to use Skorokhod's theorem stating that convergence in distribution is equivalent to almost-sure convergence of copies of the random variables in some abstract probability state. Then we just apply the usual Vitali theorem about uniform integrability for these copies. It gives convergence in mean of the copies of $X_n$ to the copy of $X$, and therefore convergence of the mean of (the copy of) $X_n$ to that of (the copy of) $X$. I put parentheses since the mean only depends on the law and hence is the same for $X_n$ or a copy of it. This is the result.

Related Question