Direct Product vs Direct Sum of Infinite Dimensional Vector Spaces – Linear Algebra

abstract-algebrafunctional-analysislinear algebravector-spaces

These seems like simple questions, but I cannot seem to find straightforward answers:

(1) If $V$ and $W$ are infinite (possibly uncountable) dimensional vector spaces, does $V \bigoplus W = V \times W$? That is, is there any difference between the direct sum and direct product of infinite dimensional vector spaces?

(2) If $\{ V_i \}_{i \in I}$ is an infinite (possibly uncountable) collection of finite dimensional vector spaces, does $ \bigoplus_{i \in I} V_i = \times_{i \in I} V_i$ ? Is the direct product product of infinitely many vector spaces even defined since vectors are supposed to consist of finite linear combinations of basis vectors (I realize there are subtleties in what "basis" means in the case of an infinite dimensional vector space)?

The inspiration for this question comes from the study of Banach spaces. Namely, that the product (or direct sum?) of Banach spaces can be made into a Banach space.

Best Answer

There is no difference between the direct sum and the direct product for finitely many terms, regardless of whether the terms themselves are infinite-dimensional or not. However, they are different in the case of infinitely many terms (and drastically so).

A direct product $\prod_{i = 1}^\infty V_i$ can be thought of as the set of sequences $(v_1, v_2, \ldots)$ where each $v_i \in V_i$, with usual scalar multiplication $\lambda (v_1, v_2, \ldots) = (\lambda v_1, \lambda v_2, \ldots)$ and pointwise addition $(v_1, v_2, \ldots) + (w_1, w_2, \ldots) = (v_1 + w_1, v_2 + w_2, \ldots)$. The direct sum $\bigoplus_{n=1}^\infty V_i$ on the other hand is the same set, with the extra condition that only finitely many terms are nonzero.

The direct sum behaves nicely in terms of bases. If each $V_i$ has some basis set $B_i \subseteq V_i$, then the direct sum $\bigoplus_{n=1}^\infty V_i$ has a basis identified with $\bigsqcup_{i=1}^\infty B_i$. For example, if all $V_i = \mathbb{R}$, then the basis for the direct product is just putting a 1 in the $i$th place for all $i$: $(1, 0, 0, \ldots), (0, 1, 0, 0, \ldots), \ldots$. In particular, if all the $V_i$ are countable dimension, the direct sum is also countable dimension.

With the direct product, this is not the case. It is not so hard to see (I'm sure there are many answers on this site) that the space of sequences of real numbers $\prod_{i=1}^\infty \mathbb{R}$ has uncountable dimension over $\mathbb{R}$.

Finally, there is not that much subtlety in what it means to be a basis of an infinite dimensional space. A basis is a linearly independent subset $B \subseteq V$ such that any vector $v \in V$ may be written as a finite linear combination of basis vectors. This is perhaps the best way to think about the difference between direct sum and product: start trying to write down a system of elements which can express any real sequence as a finite linear combination, and you'll soon see that in many cases, a direct sum may have been what you intended all along.