[Math] Closed operator

banach-spacesfunctional-analysisoperator-theory

I've got a very straightforward question : if $T : B \rightarrow B$ is a linear continuous operator and $B$ is a Banach space, is $T$ a closed operator?

This is obviously true in finite dimension, but I'm not sure what can happen in infinite dimension. Maybe it can't get "too bad" if $B$ is a Banach.

Best Answer

1) If closed means the image of every closed set is closed: No.

If this was true, any injective bounded operator with dense range would have to be surjective, whence invertible on a Banach space by the Banach isomorphism theorem. The compact diagonal operator $T(x_n)=(x_n/n)$ on $\ell^2$ is a natural counterexample.


2) If closed means the operator is closed, that is its graph is closed in $B\times B$: Yes.

Assume $(x_n,Tx_n)$ converges to $(x,y)$ in $X\times X$, that is $x_n\rightarrow x$ and $Tx_n\rightarrow y$ in $X$. By continuity of $T$, $Tx_n\rightarrow Tx$. By uniqueness of a limit in a metric space, $Tx=y$. So $(x,y)=(x,Tx)$ belongs to the graph of $T$.