[Math] Circles limits of integration with polar coordinates

polar coordinates

Footnote: Got caught up thinking it asked for a 'mutual region' in both functions, while the question actually asked for area of the second function not covered by the first function.


I have two circles:

  • Radius 1 with center (0,0), i.e. $r=1$

  • Radius 1 with center (1,0), i.e. $r=2cos(\theta)$

Hence the area equals in both cicles equals:

$$A= \int_{-\pi/3}^{\pi/3} \int_{1}^{2cos(\theta)}r \space drd\theta$$

When finding the area that is enclosed by both circles, the limits of integration according to the answer is $-\pi/3$ and $\pi/3$.

While I recognise that this is the intersection between the functions, why do I not integrate between $-\pi/2$ and $\pi/2$? It would appear that there is an region not 'covered' by these bounds of integration between the y-axis and these limits. I keep visualising that I only 'sweep' a sector of the area by doing this, missing the bits that extend beyond the limits.

Best Answer

You say the integral is "the area that is enclosed by both circles."

Actually, the integral is correct for the area in the circle with center $(1,0)$ and outside the circle with center $(0,0)$. In my diagram, it is the pure-blue area.

enter image description here

For that crescent-shaped area, the angle from the origin is indeed $60°=\frac{\pi}3$, and the distance from the origin ranges from the inner circle $r=1$ to the other circle $r=2\cos\theta$. That explains the bounds on both $r$ and $\theta$.

If you actually did want the area inside both circles and wanted to do integration from the origin, you would need three integrals: one from $-\frac{\pi}3$ to $\frac{\pi}3$ to cover $r$ from $0$ to $1$, and another from $-\frac{\pi}2$ to $-\frac{\pi}3$ to cover $r$ from $0$ to $2\cos\theta$, and a third from $\frac{\pi}3$ to $\frac{\pi}2$ to cover $r$ from $0$ to $2\cos\theta$. But this is not what your given integral apparently wants.

Related Question