For some reason, I have trouble getting absolute value right. This is of a great importance in the definition of the limit.
How do I solve the following inequality for $x$:
$$|x -a| < \epsilon$$
I know the solution is $a – \epsilon < x < a + \epsilon$, but I cannot provide the logical deductions. This is how I would start:
- $|x-a| < \epsilon$ $\iff$ $(x-a) < \epsilon$ and $(x-a) < -\epsilon$
- Simplify: $(x-a) < \epsilon$ and $-(x-a) > \epsilon$
This is where I think I go wrong because now I have a negative $x$.
Could someone show me the logical deductions step by step so I can see how it turns out?
Best Answer
You went astray right at the start: $|x-a|<\epsilon$ is emphatically not equivalent to the statement that $x-a<\epsilon$ and $x-a<-\epsilon$. It is, as M Turgeon said, equivalent to $x-a<\epsilon$ and $x-a>-\epsilon$.
One way to see this is directly from the definition of absolute value:
$$|x-a|=\begin{cases}x-a,&\text{if }x-a\ge 0\\-(x-a),&\text{if }x-a<0\;.\end{cases}$$
If $x-a\ge 0$, then $|x-a|<\epsilon$ if and only if $x-a<\epsilon$. If $x-a<0$, then $|x-a|<\epsilon$ if and only if $-(x-a)<\epsilon$, which after multiplication by $-1$ becomes $x-a>-\epsilon$. Thus, $|a-b|<\epsilon$ if and only if $x-a<\epsilon$ and $x-a>-\epsilon$, or in one statement if and only if $-\epsilon<x-a<\epsilon$. Adding $a$ to all three ‘sides’ of this then yields the desired $a-\epsilon<x<a+\epsilon$.
Another way to see it is perhaps more intuitive. For any real numbers $a$ and $b$, $|a-b|$ is simply the distance between $a$ and $b$. The condition that $|x-a|<\epsilon$ just says that the distance between $x$ and $a$ is less than $\epsilon$. This means that $x$ must be within $\epsilon$ units on either side of $a$, i.e., between $a-\epsilon$ and $a+\epsilon$. In symbols, $a-\epsilon<x<a+\epsilon$.