Is this a smooth immersion of $\Bbb R^2$ to $\Bbb R^3$

manifoldssmooth-manifolds

This has to be a smooth immersion according to John Lee's book Introduction to smooth manifolds, page 78. I compute the rank of the Jacobian matrix of the map X in an arbitrary point $(u_o,v_o)$ but after the calculations, I just showed that $\text{rank}(J(X))=1$ or $2$. It has to be $2$! I really need help. It is self-study – manifolds for about 3 years. Any help is appreciated!

Best Answer

The Jacobian matrix is $$ 2\pi\cdot\begin{bmatrix} -\sin(2\pi u)\cos(2\pi v) & -\sin(2\pi u)\sin(2\pi v)&\cos(2\pi u)\\ -(2 + \cos(2\pi u))\sin(2\pi v) & (2+\cos(2\pi u))\cos(2\pi v) & 0 \end{bmatrix} $$ (or maybe it's the transpose; I can never remember). We split into cases, depending on whether $\cos(2\pi u)= 0$.

If $\cos(2\pi u) = 0$, then $\sin(2\pi u) = \pm 1$. This reduces the matrix to $$ 2\pi\cdot\begin{bmatrix} \pm\cos(2\pi v) & \pm\sin(2\pi v)&0\\ -2\sin(2\pi v) & 2\cos(2\pi v) & 0 \end{bmatrix} $$ (where the $\pm$ stands for the same sign in both places). The determinant of the left $2\times 2$ submatrix is $$ (4\pi^2)\cdot(\pm2\cos^2(2\pi v)\pm 2\sin^2(2\pi v)) = 4\pi^2\cdot (\pm2)\neq 0 $$ which means that the first two columns are linearly independent, and the matrix has rank 2.

If $\cos(2\pi u)\neq 0$, then for the rank to be $1$, the second component of all the columns must be $0$. But $(2+\cos(2\pi u))\neq 0$, and $\sin(2\pi v)$ and $\cos(2\pi v)$ can't both be zero. So the rank must be 2.