Geometry – Proving Collinearity of Two Touching Conics

conic sectionsgeometryprojective-geometry

My friend recently played in GeoGebra and discovered an interesting fun fact:

Given two conic sections such that they have two common tangents in two different points $A$ and $B$(conics are touching, $A$ and $B$ lie on both of them, and as such, they have common tangents).
Let the intersection of those tangents be point $O$. Let us denote conics $g$ and $h$. Pick a point $F$ on $g$ and let $l$ be line tangent to $g$ in $F$ such that $l$ intersects $h$ in two points $C$ and $D$. Let $c$ and $d$ be tangents to $h$ in $C$ and $D$ respectively and let $M$ be their intersection. Prove that $O$ , $M$ and $F$ are collinear.

Of course, there are, in the Euclidean plane, degenerate cases where these points do not exist, but ignore them by assuming all intersections. We believe that this problem is easy in projective geometry, apart from the fact that there are no degenerate cases in it and talks only about incidence, but none of us had any experience, and neither did our geometry teacher succeed(we are high school students), so we ask for help.

This problem turned out to have some significance to one of our projects so we would be really grateful to see some solution soon πŸ™‚

enter image description here

Best Answer

enter image description here

The diagram has been redrawn. Added is the line $AB$, which is called the chord of contact (between the red and green ellipses). $X$ is the intersection of the lines $AB$ and $CD$.

What follows is a roadmap of a proof. The basic idea is that points $M,F,O$ are all on the polar of $X$ wrt the red conic $c$, and are thus collinear. We'll show this for each point, but the reader unfamiliar with projective geometry may have to consult the given references to make sense of things.

For some background on poles and polars see Wikipedia. The main facts we'll use here are (all poles and polars are wrt to $c$):

  • (i) let $p$ be the polar of $X$, and let $X',Y,Z$ be the points where a line going through $X$ is cut by $p$ and $c$. Then the cross ratio $(Y,Z;X,X')=-1$, i.e. $X'$ is the harmonic conjugate of $X$ wrt to $W,Z$. We say the line is cut harmonically by $X,X',Y,Z$.
  • (ii) if a point $P$ lies on the polar of point $Q$, then $Q$ lies on the polar of $P$.
  • (iii) if the tangents from $P$ to $c$ touch $c$ at $P',P''$, then the line $P'P''$ is the polar of $P$.

The red and green conics touch in two points $A,B$ and are said to be in double contact. One theorem we want is (see Milne, Cross Ratio Geometry, Article 266):

(*) Any tangent to [one conic] is cut harmonically at its point of contact, and at the points where it meets the chord of contact and the other conic.

The background of (*) will be discussed later, let's get to a proof of the OP.

$M$: by (iii), the line $CD$ is the polar of $M$. Since $X$ is on the polar of $M$, by (ii) $M$ is on the polar of $X$.

$O$: as for $M$, $X$ is on the polar of $O$ and therefore $O$ is on the polar of $M$.

$F$: by (*), the tangent $CD$ is cut harmonically by $C,D,F,X$. By (i), $F$ is on the polar of $X$.

So $M,O,F$ are all on the same line (the polar of $X$), and we are done.

Some remarks on theorem (*). This is a special case of a special case of Desargues' Theorem (Milne, Article 187), which requires a familiarity with projective involutions and their fixed points (which are related to systems of coaxal circles, which may be more familiar). So to understand it will require leafing backwards through the text, often guided by references to earlier articles. If a less rigorous understanding is acceptable, simply playing with the configuration using Geogebra and the its Polar and CrossRatio commands may suffice.

To see the special case, move the point $A$ in Milne's figure to coincide with $C$, and $B$ with $D$. So the general case of conics intersecting in four points becomes that of touching in two points. And in the above diagram, the tangent $CD$ is a special case of a line that intersects both conics.

Related Question