From $A⇒B$ and $B⇒C$ can we conclude $C$

propositional-calculus

Is the following valid:

Premises: If Bob eats breakfast, he won't eat lunch.
If Bob doesn't eat lunch he will have an early dinner
Conclusion: Bob will have an early dinner

I think this is valid. The premises are in the form $A ⇒ B, B ⇒ C$. They are telling us that $C$ is true. Then it follows that we will never have a true premise and false conclusion. Is that accurate?

Best Answer

It's invalid because we aren't given that Bob actually eats breakfast. A valid conclusion would be $A\implies C$. That is, if Bob eats breakfast then he will have an early dinner.