Can the interior of a (non-empty) smooth manifold with boundary be empty

differential-geometrydifferential-topologygeneral-topologysmooth-manifolds

Let $M$ be a smooth manifold with boundary.

If Int$M=\emptyset$, then $M=\partial M$ would be a smooth manifold without boundary, and so every point of $M$ is an interior point. Thus we have $M=$Int$M=\emptyset$.

Is my argument correct? In other words, if I have a non-empty smooth manifold $M$ with boundary, am I authorized to assume Int$M\ne \emptyset$?

Best Answer

Your argument is unusual, but correct. You invoke two well-known facts:

  1. Each manifold with boundary $M$ can be written as $M = \text{Int}M \cup \partial M$, where $\text{Int}M \cap \partial M = \emptyset$.

  2. $\partial M$ is always a manifold without boundary.

However, to prove 1. and 2. you need to consider charts as in IEm's comment. This makes clear that no boundary point can exist without interior points.

Related Question