Can any planar graph be extended into a bipartite planar graph by a series of operations

graph theoryplanar-graphs

The edge subdivision operation for an edge $\{u,v\}∈E$ is the deletion of $\{u,v\}$ from $G$ and the addition of two edges $\{u,w\}$ and $\{w,v\}$ along with the new vertex $w$.

My first question is as follows:

Can any planar graph be extended into a bipartite planar graph by a series of subdivision operations?

My initial idea was based on an equivalent description of bipartite graph.

  • A graph is bipartite if and only if it does not contain an odd cycle.

For any odd cycle, we can subdivide one of the edges to get an even cycle. But it seems possible to create some new odd cycle, as illustrated below.

enter image description here

So I'm wondering if we can eliminate all odd cycles with limited subdivision operations.


Edits: In the comments, Manuel Lafond answers above question. But I have another problem.

A planar graph $G$ which contains at least a 4-face, can we get a bipartite graph by subdividing edges in the condition of keeping all 4-faces?

We are allowed to subdivide edges other than any edges of the boundaries of all 4-faces. Now subdivision alone may not be enough to modify the original graph into a bipartite graph. for example, the triangle in the following graph cannot be eliminated by edge subdivision.

![enter image description here

So we're allowed to add new vertices and edges . We also hope to get a bipartite planar graph. But one prerequisite is that we do not destroy the 4-face.


PS: The original problem came from the proof of the following theorem.

Theorem 1. [a] For any graph $H$, there is an optimal 1-planar graph having a topological minor of $H$.

[a] Suzuki Y. K7-minors in optimal 1-planar graphs[J]. Discrete Mathematics, 2017, 340(6): 1227-1234.

Best Answer

No, it is not necessarily possible.

Suppose there is an odd face $F$, such that each adjacent face is a square, so you cannot subdivide edges of $F$. Then you are asking to add inside $F$ an arbitrary planar graph $H$, such that $F + H$ is bipartite. In $F + H$, the outer face is odd, while any inner face is even. Thus its dual graph has exactly one odd-degree vertex, which is impossible.

Related Question