Are there exotic balls

algebraic-topologygeneral-topologygeometric-topologymanifoldssmooth-manifolds

Suppose $M$ is a compact smooth manifold with boundary, which is homeomorphic to the compact ball $\mathbb{B}^d\subset \mathbb{R}^d$. Must $M$ be diffeomorphic to $\mathbb{B}^d$ or are there exotic smooth structures?

I suspect that the answer is well known or might follow from a simple argument that experts (which I am certainly not) have up their sleeves.

A natural candidate in $d=4$ would be to take $M$ to be the compact unit-ball in an exotic $\mathbb{R}^4$, but I don't know how to check whether $M$ is exotic (or even whether it has a smooth boundary to be honest).

Best Answer

In dimension 4, one has the following equivalence:

The set $\mathcal B_4$ of compact smooth manifolds homeomorphic to $B^4$, considered up to oriented diffeomorphism, is in canonical bijection with the set $\mathcal S_4$ of compact smooth manifolds homeomorphic to $S^4$, considered up to oriented diffeomorphism.

Proof. We construct maps both ways, which will be clearly inverse.

$C: \mathcal B_4 \to \mathcal S_4$. Pick $B \in \mathcal B_4$. By the resolution of the 3D Poincare conjecture, there is some oriented diffeomorphism $\varphi: \partial B \to S^3$. One may then "cap off the boundary": define $$C(B) = B \cup_\varphi B^4,$$ defined as $B \sqcup B^4$, modulo identifying $\partial B \cong S^3$ via the diffeomorphism $\varphi$.

$C$ is well-defined by Cerf's theorem that $\pi_0 \text{Diff}^+(S^3) = 1$: all diffeomorphisms are the same up to isotopy. Isotoping $\varphi$ above does not change the diffeomorphism type; so $C$ is a set map.

Conversely one has $D: \mathcal S_4 \to \mathcal B_4$, with $D(S)$ given by deleting the interior of some oriented embedding $\iota: B^4 \to S$. Oriented embeddings of balls into a connected manifold are unique up to isotopy (Palais, but straightforward); this is true in all dimensions.

Clearly $D(C(B)) = B$ (delete the ball you glued) and $C(D(S)) = S$ (glue in the ball you deleted). Therefore $C,D$ are inverse bijections.


However one has the following for $n \geq 6$.

The set $\mathcal B_n$ is trivial.

Proof: Pick $B \in \mathcal B_n$. Delete a standard ball from its interior; then we are provided with a compact manifold $W$, with $\partial W = S^{n-1} \sqcup \partial B$, so that $W \cup_{S^{n-1}} B^n = B$.

$W$ is an h-cobordism (algebra). Therefore by the h-cobordism theorem there is a diffeomorphism $W \cong S^{n-1} \times [0,1]$, which sends $S^{n-1}$ to $S^{n-1} \times \{0\}$ by the identity map. Therefore $W \cup_{S^{n-1}} B^n \cong B^n$. Therefore $B \cong B^n$.


Of course there are no exotic n-balls n = 1,2,3. For n=5 I do not know. I think the answer is that $\partial: \mathcal B_5 \to \mathcal S_4$ is an injection (maybe bijection?) but I don't know off the top of my head. Some googling or looking on Math Overflow should help. Obviously "exotic balls" will get you nowhere but some buzzwords like diffeomorphism might.

Related Question