Solved – Can categorical variables be treated as count data

categorical datacount-datapoisson distribution

In a questionnaire study, I asked for the frequency of certain behaviors using a 5-point scale. Originally, I planned to treat it as categorical, however, distribution of the answers (N=1000) turns out to be more like zero-inflated Poisson. In fact, data fit well with zero-inflated Poisson regression model. Would it be justifiable to treat categorical data as counts in such case?

It seems like the data could be seen as count information, as I asked number of behaviors (anchor of the 5-point scale was as follows: 0=never, 1=less than once a week, 2= two to three times a week, 3=almost every day, 4=everyday).

Thank you very much for your insights!

Best Answer

For a variable that was simply ordinal, it could be done; the better question is whether it should. I see several problems, starting with what is probably the most critical:

1) ordered categories are ordinal, not interval nor ratio (while the Poisson is for count data which is ratio)

2) the Poisson has non-zero probability of exceeding 5, while your variable doesn't.

However, your data consist of discretized frequencies (and that's not actually a count). You might be able to use the actual definitions of your categories to get intervals of frequencies per week, though the vagueness of category 3 is a problem; if you can argue that category 3 actually covers the territory between "more than 3 times per week but less than 7 times per week" then this variable could be handled essentially as what's effectively a set of interval-censored categories.

As such I generally still wouldn't use a Poisson model (because the content of the intervals that the categories contain don't correspond to the category labels - the weekly frequency covered by "4" isn't four times as often as the weekly frequency covered by "1", for example), but I might use something that attempted to use more of the information than treating it as a purely ordered-categorical variable.

Related Question