Intraclass Correlation – Acceptable Values for the Intraclass Correlation Coefficient (Empty Model)

intraclass-correlationmultilevel-analysisstata

I'm using xtmixed in Stata to test a Hierarchical Linear Model.
My problem is that variance at level 2 is about 4% of the total variance. So most of the variance is at level 1 and the intraclass correlation coefficient is 4%.

In other studies (different fields) I see much higher intraclass correlation coefficients (30-50%). Is there a threshold for a multilevel model to make sense? Or can I publish my results just showing the 4% (and its reduction when adding predictors to the empty model)?

Best Answer

John B. Nezlek argues that ICC should not be a ground for justifying decisions on multilevel models, because it's values could be misleading. In his article he gives a synthetic example of varying within-group relationships when intraclass correlations are 0 (attached below). So some, like Nezlek, would say that this is not a problem.

enter image description here

See: Nezlek, J.B. (2008). An Introduction to Multilevel Modeling for Social and Personality Psychology. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 2(2): 842–860.