[Physics] Impulse and force in a karate chop, can we maximize force minimizing the time of impact

collisionforcesmomentumnewtonian-mechanics

I have heard that we can maximize the force by minimizing the time of impact in a punch.

If that is true, the paradox is if we increase the time of contact with the same amount of force still we increase the impulse. Which is more reelevant force or impulse?

Best Answer

Just to clarify, impulse is force times time. Which one matters depends on what you are trying to achieve.

If you want to propell a ball thru the air, then it's the impulse that matters. Note that a ball whacked for a short time by a bat at high force can go further than you can throw by applying lower force and much longer time.

If you are trying to break a board with a karate chop, it is largely the force that matters. Once the board has cracked, which happens quickly due to the shock wave, additional applied force is of little benefit.

Related Question