In poker, which is more likely to being dealt? A pair or two-pairs?
Solve using probability.
Attempt:
First, lets find the probability of a pair. The size of sample space is ${52 \choose 5}$. Now as for the ways to pick a pair, First we select the ranks, this can be done in ${13 \choose 1}$ ways and we want 2 suits from the 4 so this we do in ${4 \choose 2 }$ ways. Now, for the remaining three cards since one rank already been chosen we only have ${12 \choose 3}$ ways to pick the ranks of remaining three and each can be chosen in ${4 \choose 1 }$ ways (1 from each suit). Thus,
$$ P( pair) = \frac{ {13 \choose 1 }{4 \choose 2 }{12 \choose 3 } { 4 \choose 1 } }{ {52 \choose 5 }}$$
Now, for two pairs, like previous part, first pick rank ${13 \choose 1 }$ and ${4 \choose 2 }$ suits. Now, for the second pair, we now pick ${12 \choose 1}$ and ${4 \choose 2 }$ suits. Finally, the last card can be chosen in ${11 \choose 1 }4 $ ways. Thus,
$$ P( 2 \; pairs) = \frac{ {13 \choose 1 } {4 \choose 2 } { 12 \choose 1 } {4 \choose 2 } {11 \choose 1 } {4 \choose 1} }{ { 52 \choose 5} } $$
Hence,
$$ \frac{ P(pair ) }{P(2 pairs) } = \frac{ {12 \choose 3 } }{ {12 \choose 1 } {4 \choose 2 }{ 11 \choose 1 } } \approx 20/3$$
So, getting a pair is 20/3 more likely than two pairs. IS this correct argument?
Best Answer
For one pair, the count should be $$\binom{13}{1}\binom{4}{2}\binom{12}{3}\binom{4}{1}^3$$ Explanation:
Thus, you forgot to apply the factor $\binom{4}{1}$ for each of the $3$ non-paired ranks.
For two pairs, the count should be $$\binom{13}{2}\binom{4}{2}^2\binom{11}{1}\binom{4}{1}$$ Explanation:
But in your count $$\binom{13}{1}\binom{4}{2}\binom{12}{1}\binom{4}{2}\binom{11}{1}\binom{4}{1}$$ the second pair could just as well have been the first, so you are counting each two-pair hand twice. Thus, your count is twice the correct count.
Using the correct counts, the ratio works out to ${\large{\frac{80}{9}}}\approx 8.9$.